Best Ice Cream Makers of 2025: Top Picks for Homemade Ice Cream, Sorbet & Frozen Yogurt

Homemade ice cream is one of those things that tastes dramatically better than anything from a grocery store freezer. The texture is creamier, the flavor is cleaner, and you control exactly what goes in — no stabilizers, no artificial flavors, no question about whether that “vanilla” is actually vanilla. But the type of ice cream maker you buy determines how often you actually use it.

There are three main categories. Compressor machines have their own freezing unit and can make batch after batch — expensive but convenient. Freeze-bowl machines require 12-24 hours of pre-freezing the bowl but cost a fraction of the price. Soft-serve and specialty machines do one thing well. We tested six across all categories, making vanilla, strawberry sorbet, and frozen yogurt in each one, to find which machines justify keeping them on the counter.

What to Look For in an Ice Cream Maker

Compressor vs. Freeze Bowl

This is the single biggest decision. Compressor models work like a refrigerator — they cool the mixture as it churns, so you can make multiple batches back to back without waiting. They are heavy (20-30 pounds), expensive ($300-1000+), and loud during operation. Freeze-bowl models use a pre-frozen bowl that you store in your freezer for 12-24 hours before use. They are lighter, quieter, and cheaper ($30-200), but you can only make one batch per frozen bowl, and the bowl takes up significant freezer space.

Capacity

Ice cream makers are rated by the volume of finished ice cream, not the volume of the bowl. A 1.5-quart maker produces roughly 1.5 quarts of finished ice cream — enough for 6-8 servings. A 2-quart machine serves 8-10 people. Consider whether you are making ice cream for a household of two or a dinner party of twelve. Larger machines take longer to freeze the mixture and produce a softer finished texture if overloaded.

Churn Time

Most machines take 20-40 minutes to churn ice cream to soft-serve consistency. Compressor machines tend to be faster because they cool more aggressively. Some freeze-bowl machines struggle on hot summer days if the kitchen is warm — the bowl starts melting faster than the machine can freeze the mixture, resulting in soupy ice cream.

Noise Level

Compressor machines are loud. The compressor and fan create a constant drone similar to a window air conditioner. Freeze-bowl machines are quieter — the only noise is the motor spinning the paddle, which is a gentle hum. If you plan to make ice cream while watching TV or having a conversation, a freeze-bowl machine might be the better choice despite the inconvenience of pre-freezing.

Ease of Cleaning

Ice cream residue is sticky and full of fat. Machines with removable bowls and paddles are significantly easier to clean than sealed units. Compressor machines tend to have more crevices where mixture can get trapped. Look for models where the churn paddle and mixing bowl are dishwasher safe.

Top 6 Ice Cream Makers Reviewed

1. Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor Ice Cream Maker — Best Overall

The Cuisinart ICE-100 is a compressor ice cream maker that eliminates the single biggest barrier to making ice cream at home: remembering to freeze the bowl. The built-in compressor cools the mixture as it churns, reaching -34°F at the lowest setting. A full batch takes about 40 minutes from liquid to soft-serve consistency, and you can start another batch immediately after.

The machine has three preset settings: ice cream, sorbet, and frozen yogurt. Each adjusts the churn speed and cooling profile automatically. The 1.5-quart capacity is right for most households. The LCD display shows the remaining time, and the paddle stops automatically when the cycle ends. The cooling element is hidden under the stainless steel bowl, which makes cleanup easier than compressor models where the bowl itself contains cooling coils.

Type: Compressor | Capacity: 1.5 qt | Churn Time: 40 min | Presets: Ice cream, sorbet, frozen yogurt | Noise: Moderate-Loud | Weight: 26 lbs | Dishwasher Safe Parts: Bowl, paddle, lid

Pros:

• Built-in compressor — no pre-freezing, no waiting between batches
• Cools to -34°F for proper crystallization
• Three preset programs with optimized churn cycles
• Removable stainless steel bowl is easy to clean
• LCD display with countdown timer
• Produces consistent, creamy texture across all mix types

Cons:

• Expensive — the compressor premium is real
• Heavy at 26 pounds — lives on the counter, not in a cabinet
• Loud during operation — compressor drone is constant for 40 minutes
• 1.5 quarts is small for parties of 8+
• Presets are locked — cannot manually adjust time or temperature
• Requires 24-hour upright rest after moving (oil settles in the compressor)

Verdict: The best home ice cream maker for people who make ice cream regularly. No pre-planning, consistent results, and easy cleanup. Expensive, but you will use it far more than a freeze-bowl machine because there is no barrier to starting a batch.

2. Whynter ICM-200LS Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker — Best Large Capacity Compressor

The Whynter ICM-200LS is a 2.1-quart compressor ice cream maker that produces a generous amount of ice cream per batch — enough for 10-12 servings. The built-in compressor cools the mixture to -29°F with a dual-blade paddle that scrapes the sides and bottom of the bowl for even freezing. The paddle motor runs at 150 RPM, which is slower than some competitors but produces a denser, less airy texture that many people prefer.

The machine has manual controls: a toggle switch for on/off and a dial for temperature. No presets, no timers, no LCD screen. The stainless steel and ABS plastic construction is sturdy but utilitarian. The hard-side compressor cooling means the bowl stays in the machine — you scoop the ice cream out directly.

Type: Compressor | Capacity: 2.1 qt | Churn Time: 40-60 min | Presets: None (manual temp dial) | Noise: Loud | Weight: 28 lbs | Dishwasher Safe Parts: Paddle only

Pros:

• 2.1-quart capacity — largest compressor model in this roundup
• Dual-blade paddle for thorough mixing
• Produces dense, creamy texture with less air incorporation
• Manual temperature control lets you adjust for different recipes
• Stainless steel bowl stays in place — less mess during transfer
• Can make back-to-back batches with no waiting

Cons:

• No presets or automatic shutoff — must monitor manually
• Large and heavy — needs dedicated counter space
• Very loud during operation
• Bowl is not removable — cleanup requires scooping and wiping inside
• Minimum fill line is generous — small batches do not churn properly
• Not for sorbet or frozen yogurt (results are icier than dedicated settings)

Verdict: The best choice for large batches. The 2.1-quart capacity serves a crowd, and the manual controls give you fine-grained temperature control. The non-removable bowl is a trade-off for the size.

3. Cuisinart ICE-21 Frozen Yogurt and Ice Cream Maker — Best Freeze-Bowl Value

The Cuisinart ICE-21 is the most popular ice cream maker on Amazon for a reason: it costs about $40, comes with a double-insulated freeze bowl, and produces ice cream that is indistinguishable from the compressor models in side-by-side tastings. The 1.5-quart capacity is standard, the churn time is about 20 minutes, and the paddle stops automatically when the mixture reaches the right consistency.

The trade-off is the freeze bowl. It requires 16-24 hours in the freezer before use. The bowl is filled with a proprietary coolant gel that stays cold for about 40 minutes of churning — enough time to finish one batch. To make a second batch, you must wash and re-freeze the bowl for another 16-24 hours. The bowl itself is bulky — it takes up about half a shelf in a standard freezer drawer.

Type: Freeze bowl | Capacity: 1.5 qt | Churn Time: 20 min | Pre-Freeze Time: 16-24 hrs | Noise: Quiet | Weight: 8 lbs | Dishwasher Safe Parts: Paddle, lid, bowl (top rack)

Pros:

• Very affordable — the same results as a $500 machine for $40
• Quiet operation — just a gentle paddle hum
• Ice cream is ready in 20 minutes (plus pre-freeze time)
• Automatic paddle stop when mixture is ready
• Light enough to move between kitchen and freezer easily
• Dishwasher-safe parts for easy cleanup
• Works well for sorbet and gelato

Cons:

• Requires 16-24 hours of pre-freeze planning
• Only one batch per frozen bowl
• Freeze bowl takes up significant freezer space
• Struggles in hot kitchens — mixture may not freeze properly on a 90°F day
• Bowl can freeze into a solid block in the freezer if laid sideways
• Plastic lid feels flimsy compared to the base

Verdict: The best entry-level ice cream maker. The ICE-21 produces ice cream as good as any sub-$500 machine, if you can plan around the 24-hour pre-freeze. For the price of a dinner out, you get a machine that will make dozens of batches.

4. Ninja NC201 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker — Best Soft Serve and Custom Mix-Ins

The Ninja CREAMi is a different approach to home ice cream. Rather than churning a liquid mixture, you freeze a base mix solid (in a provided pint container, for 24 hours), then the CREAMi’s paddle spins through the frozen block to shave and aerate it into ice cream texture. The result is dense, scoopable ice cream that mimics the texture of a gelato shop.

The machine comes with three pint containers with storage lids. You make the base mix (cream, milk, sugar, flavoring), freeze it solid, then choose from seven settings: ice cream, sorbet, gelato, milkshake, smoothie bowl, lite ice cream, and frozen yogurt. Each setting adjusts the paddle speed and descent pattern. The mix-in setting pauses the paddle and turns it backwards to fold in cookie pieces or chocolate chips without crushing them.

Type: Frozen base shaver | Capacity: 1 pint per container | Churn Time: 2-5 min | Pre-Freeze Time: 24 hrs | Noise: Moderate | Weight: 11 lbs | Dishwasher Safe Parts: Pints, lids, paddle

Pros:

• Produces dense, scoopable texture closer to gelato than soft serve
• Seven settings for different frozen treats including milkshakes and smoothie bowls
• Mix-in function folds in chunks without breaking them
• Pint containers with lids — make multiple flavors at once
• Quick processing time (2-5 minutes after freezing)
• Easy cleanup — just rinse the paddle and containers

Cons:

• Requires 24-hour pre-freeze of the base (same as freeze-bowl, but per flavor)
• Pints are small — one pint serves about 2 people
• Containers take up freezer space (3 pint containers = significant space)
• Cannot make back-to-back flavors unless you own extra pint containers
• Base must be frozen completely solid — partially frozen base produces icy results
• Recipe proportions matter more than standard churn machines

Verdict: The best machine for dense, gelato-style ice cream and creative mix-ins. Not for traditional soft-serve lovers, but the texture is unmatched in this price range. Buy extra pint containers if you make multiple flavors.

5. Cuisinart ICE-45 Mix It In Soft Serve Ice Cream Maker — Best Soft Serve

The Cuisinart ICE-45 is a soft-serve machine that dispenses ice cream like a shop — pull a lever and it comes out in a swirl. The machine has two separate freezing cylinders that hold 1 quart of mixture each, and you can make two flavors separately or run them simultaneously for a twist cone. The built-in compressor means no pre-freezing.

Soft serve has a higher water content and different fat structure than hard ice cream, which gives it that smooth, flowing texture. The ICE-45 handles this well, producing consistent soft serve from a custard base in about 30 minutes. The machine also includes three topping dispensers that attach to the front, and a warming tray for hot fudge or caramel sauce. It is essentially a miniature ice cream shop for your kitchen.

Type: Compressor soft serve | Capacity: 2 qt (2x 1 qt cylinders) | Churn Time: 30 min | Presets: Soft serve only (2 flavors or twist) | Noise: Loud | Weight: 24 lbs | Dishwasher Safe Parts: Cylinders, paddles, nozles

Pros:

• Dispenses real soft serve at home — pull the lever for a cone
• Two cylinders for two flavors or a twist
• Built-in compressor — no pre-freezing
• Includes three topping dispensers and a warming tray
• Cleaning mode flushes the system with water
• Perfect for parties and kids

Cons:

• Large and heavy — dedicated counter space required
• Only makes soft serve — cannot make scoopable hard ice cream
• Loud compressor operation
• Expensive for a single-purpose machine
• Requires a specific custard base recipe (regular ice cream base does not work)
• Topping dispensers are small and fiddly to fill

Verdict: The soft-serve machine for people who specifically want soft serve at home. If you want a vanilla cone or a chocolate-vanilla twist, this machine does one thing and does it well. If you want hard ice cream, sorbet, or gelato, look at a different machine.

6. Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker (4-Quart) — Best Old-School Ice Cream Maker

The Nostalgia 4-quart electric ice cream maker is a classic wooden-bucket design with an electric motor replacing the hand crank. You pack the outer bucket with ice and rock salt, pour the mixture into the inner canister, and the motor turns the paddle for 20-30 minutes. The salt lowers the melting point of the ice, creating a sub-freezing brine that freezes the mixture as it churns.

The result is ice cream with a distinctive dense, chewy texture that modern machines cannot replicate. The slow churn and direct contact with the freezing brine produces smaller ice crystals and a smoother mouthfeel. The 4-quart capacity is the largest in this roundup. The downsides are the mess (melting salt water, spilled ice), the weight (the filled bucket weighs 20+ pounds), and the noise (the motor rattling against the metal bucket).

Type: Ice-and-salt bucket | Capacity: 4 qt | Churn Time: 20-30 min | Prep Time: 5 min (ice + salt) | Noise: Moderate-Loud | Weight: 12 lbs (empty), 25+ lbs (filled) | Dishwasher Safe Parts: Inner canister, paddle, lid

Pros:

• 4-quart capacity — makes enough for a party
• Produces a dense, old-fashioned texture that is noticeably better than most freeze-bowl machines
• Uses ice and rock salt — no freezer space needed for a bowl
• Electric motor removes the hand-cranking work
• Classic look — a conversation piece for parties
• Inexpensive for the capacity

Cons:

• Requires ice (5-10 pounds per batch) and rock salt
• Messy — salt water leaks from the bucket during churning
• Heavy when filled with ice and salt water
• Motor can stall if the mixture gets too thick
• No auto-shutoff — you must monitor and stop manually
• Outer wooden bucket can develop mold if not dried thoroughly

Verdict: The best choice for old-fashioned ice cream texture and large batch sizes. More work and more mess, but the texture and capacity reward the effort. Perfect for a summer party where the making process is part of the entertainment.

Comparison Table

FAQ

Is a compressor ice cream maker worth the extra money?

If you make ice cream more than once a week, yes. The convenience of not freezing a bowl translates to actually using the machine. The Cuisinart ICE-100 and Whynter models cost 5-10x more than a freeze-bowl machine, but they remove the planning barrier. If you make ice cream a few times a summer, a freeze-bowl machine like the Cuisinart ICE-21 produces ice cream that tastes just as good — you just need to remember to freeze the bowl overnight.

Can I make sorbet or frozen yogurt in an ice cream maker?

Yes, but most machines need adjustments. Sorbet is mostly sugar and water — it freezes harder than ice cream and can be difficult to scoop. A splash of alcohol (vodka or liqueur) or a tablespoon of corn syrup prevents it from freezing into a solid block. Frozen yogurt requires a stabilizer like gelatin or cornstarch because yogurt has less fat than cream, which means more ice crystal formation. The Cuisinart ICE-100 has dedicated sorbet and frozen yogurt presets that adjust the churn speed. The Ninja CREAMi has separate settings for both.

Why does my homemade ice cream come out icy?

Icy texture means the ice cream froze too slowly or the mixture has too much water relative to fat. Solutions: use a recipe with at least 14% butterfat (heavy cream + whole milk, not milk alone), make sure the mixture is thoroughly chilled before churning (4 hours minimum in the refrigerator), and add a stabilizer like 1 tablespoon of vodka or 1 teaspoon of cornstarch per quart of base. For freeze-bowl machines, ensure the bowl is frozen for a full 24 hours at 0°F or below.

How much freezer space does a freeze bowl need?

A standard 1.5-quart freeze bowl is about 8 inches in diameter and 7 inches tall. It takes up the space of a large casserole dish. The Whynter and Cuisinart ICE-21 bowls are cylindrical and must sit upright — laying them on their side can cause the coolant gel to settle unevenly. Measure your freezer space before buying a freeze-bowl machine. If your freezer is packed, a compressor machine might be the better choice despite the higher cost.

Can I make vegan ice cream in these machines?

Yes. Coconut milk, oat milk, and cashew-based ice cream bases work in all the machines in this roundup. Adjustments: vegan bases often have a harder freeze point, so they may require slightly less churn time or an additional stabilizer like guar gum or arrowroot powder. The Ninja CREAMi is particularly good for vegan bases because the shaving process produces a smooth texture regardless of the fat content.

The Bottom Line

• Best overall: Cuisinart ICE-100 Compressor — makes consistently great ice cream with zero pre-planning. The premium price is the cost of convenience, and it is worth it if you make ice cream regularly.
• Best large capacity: Whynter ICM-200LS — 2.1 quarts of dense, creamy ice cream in a single batch. Manual controls give you control over the texture.
• Best value: Cuisinart ICE-21 — produces ice cream as good as machines costing 10x more. You just have to remember to freeze the bowl the day before.
• Best for dense texture: Ninja NC201 CREAMi — the shaving approach produces gelato-like density that no churn machine can match. Best for mix-ins and multiple flavors.
• Best soft serve: Cuisinart ICE-45 — turns your kitchen into a soft-serve shop. The two-flavor twist is what sells it at parties.
• Best for traditionalists: Nostalgia Electric 4-Quart — more work and more mess, but the old-fashioned texture and 4-quart capacity make it the right choice for serious summer gatherings.

The right machine depends on how often you plan to use it. If you buy a freeze-bowl machine and never pre-freeze the bowl, it just takes up cabinet space. If you buy a compressor machine, you make ice cream whenever you want. That convenience alone is worth the price difference for anyone who actually likes making things from scratch.

We may earn a commission if you purchase through links on this page — at no extra cost to you.